Ms. Blakk For President (c) Carol Rosegg
Theater: Ms. Blakk For President
At the Vineyard Theatre
It must have been a different experience watching Tarell Alvin McCraney and Tina Landau’s play Ms. Blakk For President at its world premiere in 2019 at Steppenwolf Theater in Chicago versus today in the blue new world of New York of 2026. The play, which focuses on real life black gay drag queen Terence Alan Smith (a fabulous Ato Blankson-Wood, stepping in for an ailing Wayne Brady, who had to drop out) who ran against Richard M. Daley the mayor of Chicago as his alter ego Joan Jett Blakk in 1991. Once content with just performing in small clubs, lip-synching to Janis Joplin, Smith is challenged by Queer Nation member Mark (a fiery Gideon Glick) to get involved with confronting politicians on their lack of action around the AIDS crisis. Thus, the Miss Blakk campaign is born, and she projects a Nancy Regan feel, fabulously outspoken and fun, to shake up the status quo. Spoiler Alert: Ms. Blakk doesn’t win. But as the National Democratic Convention in New York City approaches, can Ms. Blakk reprise her role in the Presidential race against Bill Clinton? After the Bluenami of Election Day 2026, why not? But back in 1992, things are more dangerous for people not of the status quo, and the play does a good job balancing the fierceness of Blakk and the dangers she faces. The rest of the ensemble (Adina Verson, Nic Ashe, Kelvin Moon Loh and Sawyer Smith) are all excellent playing various characters throughout, and so fun during the catwalk pre-show on the playful set by David Zinn, focused lighting by Bradley King, mischievous costumes by Ari Fulton and exuberant sound design by Lindsay Jones (excluding an unnecessarily loud sound cue). Be sure not to miss the exhibit of historical news items about the real Smith—the play’s version of events is somewhat fictionalized. I was glad to be introduced to this fascinating personality, especially as embodied by the outstanding Blankson-Wood. She was certainly ahead of her time, and I enjoyed spending an evening at the theater with such a strong, gay, brave figure.
Rope (c) Monique Carboni
Theater: Rope
The New Group at The Theatre at St. Clements
Playwright Gordon Greenberg’s adaptation of Alfred Hitchcock’s film Rope (which in itself is based on a 1929 play, loosely based on the real-life Leopold and Loeb case) has decided the subtext of the film needs to be put front and center. The play seems to take a page out of Tom Stoppard’s playbook and showing us all the stuff missing from the film that censors would have taken out (A “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern Are Gay,” if you will.) Garrett (Cameron Monaghan) and Nate (Corey Fogelmanis) are already on a mostly bare stage, in various state of undress when the audience enters. They start the play by bringing in all the furniture and rugs to create a smart, upper-class apartment in Manhattan, designed by Derek McLane, including the all-important chest that really brings the room together. That is where the pair has hidden the body of Ronald, their Princeton classmate, whom they just killed right before guests are to arrive for a dinner party. Their sick joke is that no one will know what’s really in the chest, especially not Ronald’s father (James Waterston). Also invited are another classmate, the loveably clueless Richard (a game Graham Phillips), their longtime friend Leila (Elizabeth Gillies) and Rupert (Jason Butler Harner), Garrett’s professor and possible side piece, something not even hinted at in the film, where the character was played by straight-laced Jimmy Stewart.
Rope (c) Monique Carboni
Greenberg’s script takes a lot of liberties with the film, which purists will balk at, but as a non-acolyte, I found the play taken on its own a pretty suspenseful, filled with gay longing and manipulation. Scott Elliott’s excellent direction creates a believably 1950s atmosphere, immensely aided by Catherine Zuber’s smart costumes. The actors have a fun time with Greenberg’s period dialogue (adding the sentence-ending “is all” to many lines), especially by Gillies, who gets to deliver a lot of the funnier lines as well as sing a song. Monaghan, mostly known from the TV show Shameless, is making an impressive NYC stage debut as the more diabolical of the lovers, but Harner steals the show, with the gay longing element a sad character addition. The controversial ending may be a bridge too far from the film, and while it feels excessive, it certainly wasn’t safe. I hope Rope has an extended life after its initial run (which has already been extended) because the aura is sexy, the mood is edge-of-your-seat, and the post-theater discussions are lively.
The Unbelievers (c) Matthew Murphy
Theater: The Unbelievers
Manhattan Theatre Club at New York City Center
Religion feels like a red herring in Nick Payne’s latest play, The Unbelievers, including the title, the set by Paul Steinberg (which seats a quarter of the audience on church pews on stage) and a reverend character who prays and provides spiritual support throughout. But the biggest religious clue is that the evening starts with Miriam (Lauren Ambrose) lighting a candle that stays lit nearly the entire almost two-hour runtime. Turns out the title actually describes every character in the play who’s not Miriam as she is the only one who believes her son, Oscar, who disappears on day after school, is still alive, even many years after he vanished. Like many a Payne play, the story is nonlinear, so we get three main timelines: the days and weeks after the disappearance, a year later and five years later, with Ambrose giving a virtuoso performance (with the help of director Knud Adams), changing her emotions at the snap of a finger as Payne blends the timeline, as if these events are all blending in Miriam’s mind into one big trauma. The whole ensemble is effective: Tom Riley as David, Miriam’s estranged husband; Nina Ross and Elizabeth Yeoman as her other children; as well as Hadai Tabbal as her ex-husband; Marjan Neshat (who starred in the excellent English with Tabbal, also directed by Adams) as both a sympathetic police investigator and David’s new girlfriend, with Jaspal Binning and Brittany Bradford in smaller roles. The Unbelievers is not an easy play to watch as it’s essentially one woman’s helpless cry into the void of heartbreak. But it is also a production you can’t easily shake after seeing it.
2:22 - A Ghost Story (c) Evan Zimmerman
Theater: 2:22 – A Ghost Story
At the Lucille Lortel Theatre
Danny Robins’ play 2:22 – A Ghost Story was a big success in London when it opened in 2021 and has come back to the West End more times than A Christmas Carol since its premiere. It has finally made it to New York in a handsome production co-directed by original director Matthew Dunster (with Gabriel Vega Weissman), but unfortunately after another British hit — Paranormal Activity — which shares a similar DNA opened on Broadway earlier this summer. Both plays focus on a creaky old house in England, with a new couple, here Jenny (Jasmine Cephas Jones) and Sam (Finn Jones from Marvel’s Iron Fist), with the wives sure that something creepy is going on and the husbands dismissing their fears as silly. In Jenny’s case, the spookiness always seems to happen at 2:22 a.m., and when Sam returns from a work trip, she convinces him and their friends Lauren (Anna Camp) and Ben (Martin Marquez) to stay up that night to prove she isn’t crazy. Until the time arrives (and we have a huge digital clock to count it down), the couples get progressively drunker and secrets come out—Lauren may still have a crush on Sam since they were in school. The problem with this premise is that if all the bad stuff happens at 2 a.m., then how can this production compare to the unearthly scares that Paranormal Activity seems to employ every 10 minutes? Robins’ script conveniently provides a pack of coyotes roaming the neighborhood that screech whenever things get too serene, while Dunster and Weissman end each scene with a (very) loud noise that has nothing to do with the play but keeps the audience on its toes. So, in comparison to Paranormal, this more modest character study is lacking, but it does have charms of its own with a smart quartet of actors trying to sell every bump in the night, even though I figured out the big twist long before a child’s toy is set on fire or the big séance that ends the evening. 2:22 – A Ghost Story is a fun night out, but this ghost may not be as spooky as audiences might be expecting.
If you want to comment on these reviews, please do so on my Instagram account. All reviews have their own post. And please follow to know when new reviews are released.




